DePaul University

Student Housing Case Study: DePaul University

Operational Assessment

Chicago, IL

Campus Advantage was engaged by the trustee of a purpose-built student-housing community in the DePaul marketplace in March 2011. Campus Advantage team members interviewed site staff, toured the property, conducted student intercept surveys, reviewed historical documents, and surveyed the market. Operational data and budgets provided by the owner were also reviewed to create a comparative budget using industry benchmarks to illustrate the variances associated with the property versus an average property of this size.

CA’s assessment of operational strengths and opportunities for growth included the following categories:

Market Factors

  • Overview of competitive properties in the market
  • Rate comparison to market averages
  • Enrollment trends for DePaul

Marketing and Leasing

  • Social media use
  • Website review to increase usability
  • Property signage
  • Printed marketing assets including mail pieces
  • Opportunities to increase leasing traffic
  • Training to increase closing rates 

Facilities

  • Review of service contracts
  • FF&E assessment

Residence Life

  • Staffing / job duties assessment
  • Event schedule review
  • Campus relations advising

Budget Review

  • Utility cost comparison to local market rates

Campus Advantage was subsequently engaged to provide ongoing operations consulting to assist with the implementation of our recommendations. In the month’s following our consulting, occupancy at the property rose 22 percentage points for the beginning of the 2011-2012 academic year.

University of New Hampshire

Student Housing Case Study: University of New Hampshire

Operational Assessment

Varsity Place Apartments – Focused on NOI Enhancements

Campus Advantage was contracted by a portfolio owner to conduct an operational assessment for several properties serving students at the University of New Hampshire. This operational assessment focused on identifying issues or challenges related to market factors, staffing and leasing, and operations and facilities. Campus Advantage made specifically targeted recommendations for changes or improvements that could result in achieving the higher occupancy and NOI for the property.

Market Factors considered for this property included:

  • Successfully leasing a very large variety of unit types
  • A large number of recent and upcoming developments
  • Marketing and residence life improvement adjustments
  • Recommendations focused on increasing returning resident ratios

Staffing and Leasing

  • Recommendations to develop a full residence life program
  • Incorporating resident events as a part of the marketing plan
  • Employing a social media plan

Operations and Facilities

  • Property tax recommendations
  • Overview of benefits and efficiencies of offering inclusive rates

Campus Advantage team members interviewed site staff, toured the communities, and surveyed the market. Operational data, sales reports, current rent rolls, and budgets provided by the owner were also reviewed. Additionally, interviews were conducted with the Durham City Planner to gain insight into future developments planned for this market.

University of California – Berkeley

Student Housing Case Study: University of California – Berkeley

New Development and Student Survey

Green Living / Sustainable Community – Client: Undisclosed

Campus Advantage was engaged in March 2011 to perform an analysis of a proposed 600-bed student housing development in Berkeley, CA. The focus of the analysis was to determine whether a sufficient market existed for a new off-campus student housing project with a significant sustainability component (LEED Platinum and/or Living Building Challenge), and if the market conditions supported the investment required to develop such product.

Campus Advantage’s research included a large-scale, statistically valid student survey; university overview, including enrollment trend analysis; and a market analysis, including both existing competitors and future construction. The aforementioned student survey included a large component dedicated to evaluating student opinion of a variety of sustainable FF&E, options including various community amenities and in-unit energy budgeting hardware. Additional components of this study included references to the city’s development plan for the subject site neighborhood and a review of the Living Building Challenge.

Through extensive market research and analysis, Campus Advantage concluded that the proposed project appeared viable with a likelihood of success and supported this conclusion with collected market data and a financial pro forma for the property.

Wayne State University

Student Housing Case Study: Wayne State University

New Development

Detroit, MI – Client: The Union at Midtown

Campus Advantage was engaged in early 2008 by a private developer to perform a market analysis and feasibility study for a site in Detroit near the Wayne State University campus. Campus Advantage evaluated the on- and off-campus housing market, analyzed historical enrollment trends and future growth at the University, and conducted informal interviews with students to determine the potential demand for a new student housing development.

As a result of the study, Campus Advantage came to the conclusion that the Detroit student market could absorb the proposed project, given its superior location and lack of other purpose-built product in the market. The Wayne State market could be characterized by properties that were built in the early 1900s and contained 100 beds or less. One- and two-bedroom apartments were most prevalent, with only two properties offering a three-or four-bedroom option. Furthermore, very few properties included any amenities, furnishings, or an all-inclusive rent option. The Union at Midtown, with 140 beds on three levels and ground-floor retail, offered a unique living experience for students in this market and leased to 90% before opening in fall 2011.

Virginia Commonwealth University

Student Housing Case Study: Virginia Commonwealth University

New Development

Richmond, VA – Client: 8 ½ Canal

Campus Advantage was originally retained in September 2009 to perform a market profile of the Virginia Commonwealth housing market. The focus of the analysis was to make general assumptions regarding the on- and off-campus housing market at VCU and evaluate the potential demand for a new student housing development. As a direct result of the data gathered during the market profile, the developer then engaged the CA team to conduct a more in-depth analysis of the project and produce a full Market Analysis and Project Feasibility Study. This level of research required members of the Campus Advantage team to travel to Richmond to meet with VCU and City of Richmond officials, as well as perform intercept surveys with VCU students.

Campus Advantage concluded that the Richmond student market had the depth to absorb the proposed project, given the fast-growing student population at VCU and the project’s superior location. The site was located in an up-and-coming area of the market, due to recent campus expansion. Additionally, the off-campus Richmond market lacked any purpose-built student product. The majority of the properties surveyed in the main student housing corridors had very limited amenities, especially those geared toward students, such as a residence life program or all-inclusive rates. 8 ½ Canal was the first purpose-built property to enter the Richmond market and offered a plethora of amenities. The property also introduced an abundance of four-bedroom apartments, a unit type only found in one other off-campus property.

Construction on 8 ½ Canal began in summer 2010 for a fall opening in 2011. The Campus Advantage team was once again engaged to perform the initial operations and lease-up of the property, pre-leasing the property to 100% before it opened in fall 2011. The fast lease-up and continued success of the property exhibits the desirability of purpose-built product in an untested market.

The building includes 160 units with 540 beds on six levels and parking on two levels. 8 ½ Canal is also an eco-friendly project which was designed with green principles in mind in accordance with the LEED accreditation system.

524 Angliana

Student Housing Case Study: 524 Angliana

Project Results: Property opened for fall 2009 at 75% occupancy. Achieved 100% occupancy fall 2010. Successful exit fall 2010 with a purchase price of $43 million, a realized capital gain of approximately $7.3 million, and an equity multiple of 1.8x.
  • Role: Design consulting, market analysis/feasibility, initial operations/lease-up, property management
  • Location: Lexington, KY (University of Kentucky)
  • Open: August 2009
  • Total Cost: $35.7 million
  • Equity: $8.9 million
  • Beds: 740
  • Strategy: Purpose Built Development

8 1/2 Canal

Student Housing Case Study: 8 1/2 Canal

Project Results: Property opened for Fall 2011 at 100% occupancy. Through the first six months of operations, NOI is 11% ahead of budget with a projected year 1 NOI of approximately $3 million, for a yield on cost of 11%. The current market value is estimated at $38.5 million.
  • Role: Design consulting, market analysis/feasibility, initial operations/lease-up, property management
  • Location: Richmond, VA (Virginia Commonwealth University)
  • Open: August 2011
  • Total Cost: $27 million
  • Beds: 540
  • Strategy: Purpose Built Development